Salary vs Dividends – How to Pay Yourself as a Contractor in 2025

“The way you pay yourself could be the single biggest factor affecting your take-home income as a contractor.”

That might sound dramatic, but after working with hundreds of contractors across the UK, we’ve seen it time and again — two contractors earning the same profit can walk away with wildly different amounts in their pocket, simply because one understood how to balance salary and dividends, and the other didn’t.

At Zeus Accountants, we spend a lot of time helping our clients figure out the smartest, most tax-efficient way to pay themselves. And let’s be honest — it’s not always straightforward. Between dividend tax rates, National Insurance thresholds, corporation tax changes, and IR35 rules, it’s no wonder so many contractors feel lost.

So in this guide, we’ll break it all down in plain English. No jargon, no fluff — just practical, 2025-ready advice.

Let’s start with the big question: salary or dividends?

Salary vs Dividends – Related Questions

How do I decide between salary and dividends as a limited company contractor?

This is the classic question. Most contractors know they can pay themselves in two main ways: a salary (through payroll) or dividends (from company profits). But the real challenge is knowing which one makes more sense — and when.

Understanding your company’s profit position

Before deciding, look at your company’s performance. A contractor who brings in steady monthly income might prefer regular salary payments for predictability. But if your cash flow fluctuates, dividends might offer flexibility.

At Zeus, we often advise contractors to base their decision on post-tax profit. Dividends can only be paid from profits after corporation tax, so if you’ve had a slower quarter, taking more dividends could put you at risk of breaching the Companies Act.

Balancing personal tax with company savings

A salary reduces your company’s profit, which in turn reduces your corporation tax bill. Dividends, on the other hand, don’t — they come out after tax. So it’s all about balance: a low salary for tax efficiency, topped up with dividends for flexibility.

I remember working with a client, Sarah, a project manager from Manchester. She used to take a high salary thinking it looked better for mortgage purposes. But when we recalculated her tax position, we found she could save over £3,200 per year by shifting more income into dividends — without affecting her borrowing potential.

When to prioritise dividends vs salary

Here’s a simple rule of thumb for 2025:

• Salary is best for maintaining NI credits, pension contributions, and personal allowance benefits.

• Dividends are best for extracting profits efficiently once you’ve hit your desired salary threshold.

Can I pay myself a mix of salary and dividends?

Absolutely — in fact, that’s what most successful contractors do.

Typical ratios used by contractors

The most common split we see is a low salary (around the NI threshold, roughly £12,570 in 2025/26) and the rest in dividends. This ensures you get NI credits toward your pension but avoid paying unnecessary National Insurance.

How to document dividend payments correctly

When paying dividends, documentation is essential. You’ll need to issue a dividend voucher (even if it’s to yourself) and record the payment in your company’s minutes. It sounds formal, but HMRC can and does ask for these records during compliance checks.

The benefits of a blended pay approach

This hybrid model keeps things efficient, simple, and flexible. You can adjust dividends throughout the year as your profits fluctuate — something salaried employees can’t do. It’s one of the biggest advantages of operating through your own limited company.

How do dividends affect my personal tax bill?

This is where many contractors trip up — dividends may be “tax-efficient,” but they’re not “tax-free.”

How dividend income interacts with your personal allowance

Everyone has a personal allowance (£12,570) and a separate dividend allowance, which for 2025/26 is just £500. That’s a sharp drop from previous years — meaning more dividend income now falls into taxable bands.

The 2025/26 dividend tax bands explained

Here’s how it breaks down:

• Basic rate: 8.75%

• Higher rate: 33.75%

• Additional rate: 39.35%

So, if you’re earning dividends that push you into the higher-rate band, those savings can evaporate quickly.

Example tax calculation for contractors

Let’s say your limited company makes £70,000 profit before tax. After paying 25% corporation tax (£17,500), you have £52,500 left.

If you take a £12,570 salary and the rest as dividends, your total tax could be around £8,500.

But if you took it all as salary, it would be over £13,000. That’s a £4,500 saving — and that’s why dividends remain the contractor’s friend in 2025.

What’s the most tax-efficient salary/dividend split in 2025/26?

This changes slightly each year as thresholds shift, but in 2025/26, the sweet spot is likely similar to the previous year’s: a salary at the NI limit, and the rest in dividends.

Recommended thresholds and allowances

Most contractors will benefit from:

• Salary: around £12,570 per year

• Dividends: up to your basic rate limit (around £37,700) before hitting higher-rate tax

This gives you a total income of about £50,270 while staying within the basic rate band.

Balancing NIC savings with pension eligibility

A small salary ensures you still qualify for state pension and certain benefits. If you skip salary altogether, you risk missing out on those National Insurance credits.

How to stay compliant while maximising take-home pay

HMRC loves documentation. Make sure your dividend minutes, vouchers, and board resolutions are properly prepared — even if you’re the only director. At Zeus, we automate this process for our clients to keep it stress-free and compliant.

How does corporation tax affect dividend payments?

This is one of the biggest misconceptions we see. You pay corporation tax before you can issue dividends — not after.

Paying corporation tax before dividends

So if your company earns £100,000, you must first pay corporation tax (at 25% for most contractors in 2025). Only then can you take dividends from what’s left.

The link between company profits and available dividends

If your balance sheet shows negative retained earnings (for example, because you took too much last year), you legally can’t pay dividends — even if you have cash in the bank.

Timing dividend declarations for tax efficiency

Timing can make a huge difference. Some clients prefer to declare dividends just before their financial year-end to balance profits and tax, while others wait until after the year closes to confirm exact figures. Both can work — but it’s all about planning.

How much can I take out of my company without paying extra tax?

That depends on your total income and how much profit the company has after tax.

Understanding your personal tax bands

If you stay within the basic rate band (£50,270 total income), your dividend tax rate remains at 8.75%. Once you go above that, it jumps to 33.75% — a big difference.

Using director’s loans and retained profits wisely

Sometimes you may need cash before profits are finalized. That’s where director’s loans come in. You can take short-term funds from the company, but these must be repaid within nine months of the year-end to avoid extra tax charges.

Avoiding overdrawn director’s loan accounts

We once helped a contractor who unknowingly built up a £10,000 overdrawn director’s loan account — and ended up paying a 32.5% s455 tax charge. A quick review and repayment plan saved him thousands the next year. Moral of the story: track your withdrawals closely.

Is it better to leave profits in the company or take dividends?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. It depends on your goals.

When retaining profits makes financial sense

If you don’t need the cash immediately, leaving profits in your company can fund future investments, pension contributions, or expansion. It can also help you avoid pushing your personal income into a higher tax bracket.

The tax impact of reinvesting vs withdrawing

Taking dividends triggers personal tax. Keeping funds in the company keeps that money working for you — at least until you need it. Some contractors even use retained profits to buy equipment or invest through the company.

Future planning considerations for contractors

Remember, tax rules change every year. What’s efficient now might not be in 2026. That’s why at Zeus Accountants, we review every client’s pay strategy annually — adjusting for rate changes, allowances, and personal circumstances.

What’s the best way to pay yourself if you’re the only director?

Solo directors have flexibility, but they also carry the full compliance burden.

Streamlining admin with low salary/high dividend structure

The simplest approach: a minimal salary through PAYE (to secure NI credits) and dividends taken quarterly or biannually. It’s predictable, clean, and highly efficient.

How to keep payroll compliant

Even if you pay yourself a low salary, you still need to register for PAYE. Many contractors overlook this, but HMRC expects directors’ salaries to be processed through payroll.

Managing cash flow as a solo contractor

Cash flow is king. Always set aside 20–25% of your income for tax. We’ve seen too many talented contractors struggle because they forgot to separate personal and company finances.

Can I pay myself a salary below the National Insurance threshold?

You can — and sometimes it makes sense.

The benefits and drawbacks of a low salary

A salary below the NI threshold avoids NI contributions, saving a bit of tax. But if you go too low, you lose access to state benefits and pension credits.

State pension and benefit implications

As of 2025, you need around 35 qualifying years of NI contributions to get the full State Pension. Paying yourself nothing could create gaps that cost you thousands in retirement.

When it might be worth paying more

If you’re close to retirement age or planning for mortgage applications, paying a slightly higher salary might make sense. It’s about balance, not extremes.

How do salary and dividends affect my pension contributions?

This one’s crucial — and often overlooked.

Employer vs personal pension contributions

Your company can make employer pension contributions directly, which are usually tax-deductible against profits. This is one of the most efficient ways to extract money from your business.

Salary limits for personal pension tax relief

If you make personal contributions, your tax relief is limited to your salary amount — not dividends. That’s another reason a modest salary is valuable.

Making pension contributions tax-efficiently

We usually suggest blending employer and personal contributions, aligning them with your overall pay strategy. For instance, one of our clients in Brighton pays herself a £12,570 salary, £30,000 in dividends, and £10,000 into her pension — a perfect balance between tax efficiency and future planning.

📊 Tax and Compliance Questions

If you’ve been a contractor for a while, you already know: taxes aren’t just numbers. They’re decisions. Every financial move — from when you declare a dividend to how you handle corporation tax — carries consequences.

At Zeus Accountants, we’ve seen even the most diligent professionals overpay, simply because they didn’t understand the order of things. Let’s unpack it properly.

What are the current dividend tax rates for 2025/26?

The dividend tax landscape has changed drastically over the last few years. What used to be a £2,000 tax-free allowance is now just £500 — and that’s a game-changer.

Dividend tax bands explained

For the 2025/26 tax year:

• Basic rate: 8.75%

• Higher rate: 33.75%

• Additional rate: 39.35%

Let’s make this real.

We recently worked with Dan, a contractor in Kent earning £80,000 through his limited company. He took a small salary of £12,570 and the rest as dividends. When we crunched the numbers, about £27,000 of those dividends fell into the higher-rate bracket. That meant he owed 33.75% on that portion — roughly £9,100 in dividend tax.

Now, that sounds painful, right? But when we restructured his strategy — by increasing his pension contribution and deferring part of his dividend into the next tax year — he cut that bill by nearly £2,800. Timing and planning make all the difference.

Comparing dividend vs salary tax rates

When you take a salary, both you and your company pay National Insurance. Dividends avoid that. That’s the key reason dividends remain more tax-efficient, even with lower allowances.

How tax thresholds affect your total income

The magic number is still £50,270 — the upper limit for the basic rate. Once your combined income (salary + dividends) crosses that line, you start paying 33.75%. That’s when you need to start thinking strategically about timing and pension contributions.

How much is the dividend allowance in 2025/26?

It’s small — painfully small — but it still counts.

The new £500 dividend allowance

That £500 might not seem like much, but think of it as the “free space” where you can take dividends with no personal tax. For many clients, we use it as a planning lever: taking exactly that amount from retained profits at year-end just to make use of the allowance.

Combining personal and dividend allowances

When combined with your £12,570 personal allowance, it gives you a modest buffer before paying any income tax. But with the allowance reduced, contractors are now relying more on salary optimisation and pension planning to reduce overall tax.

Adjusting your pay plan for reduced allowances

If your pay strategy hasn’t changed in two years, it’s time for a review. Many contractors are still operating under the assumption that the dividend allowance is £2,000 — it’s not. At Zeus Accountants, we help clients simulate their take-home pay under the new rates using real-time accounting tools. The savings from minor adjustments often reach four figures.

Do I pay corporation tax before or after dividends?

Always before.

Order of payments: profits → tax → dividends

Your company earns profit, pays corporation tax on that profit, and then you can distribute what’s left as dividends. You can’t pay dividends out of gross profit.

Example calculation of post-tax profit distribution

Suppose your company earns £60,000 before tax.

Corporation tax (25%) = £15,000

Remaining = £45,000

That’s your maximum dividend pool. Anything beyond that is illegal.

Avoiding common mistakes in dividend timing

One of our clients, Priya, used to take monthly “dividends” like a salary. Her company hadn’t yet earned enough profit mid-year to cover them, so she was technically paying illegal dividends. We helped her correct it, but it was a stressful (and expensive) lesson. The takeaway? Always check your retained earnings before paying yourself.

Are dividends subject to National Insurance?

No — and that’s their biggest advantage.

How NICs differ for salary and dividends

Salaries trigger both employer and employee National Insurance. Dividends don’t. That’s where the bulk of the savings come from.

Why this makes dividends more tax-efficient

On a £50,000 income, avoiding NI can save you over £4,000 per year. That’s significant — and one of the main reasons contractors choose to operate through limited companies.

When NICs may still apply indirectly

Indirectly, though, a low salary might affect your State Pension and benefits. So while dividends avoid NI, a completely salary-free strategy isn’t ideal long-term.

Do I have to pay income tax on dividends from my own company?

Yes, but it’s charged at separate rates from your employment income.

Understanding personal dividend taxation

HMRC treats dividends as income on top of your salary. So, your salary uses up part of your personal allowance and basic rate band first.

How HMRC calculates your total income tax

For example, if you earn £12,570 salary and £37,700 in dividends, your total taxable income is £50,270. You’ll pay around £3,200 in tax — still far lower than if that were all salary.

Reporting your dividend income properly

You’ll declare dividends on your Self-Assessment Tax Return each January. Always keep your dividend vouchers and board minutes — HMRC occasionally asks to see proof, even years later.

How do I calculate how much dividend I can pay?

This is where many contractors get caught out.

Using retained profit and balance sheet data

Dividends can only come from retained profits — the accumulated, after-tax profits your company has built up over time.

Declaring dividends legally

When you decide to pay one, you need:

1. A board minutes confirming the declaration

2. A dividend voucher for your records

3. An accounting entry showing the payment

Example: safe dividend distribution formula

A quick formula we often teach our clients:

Available dividends = Retained earnings + Current profit (after tax) – Any director’s loans owed to the company

This ensures you never pay more than you should — and keeps you safe from “illegal dividend” accusations.

Can I pay dividends if my company made a loss?

No — and this is crucial.

Why you can’t pay dividends from negative reserves

Dividends represent a share of profit. If your company has negative retained earnings (a loss), there are no profits to distribute — even if there’s money in the bank.

Legal and accounting implications

Paying dividends in this case isn’t just a bad idea; it’s unlawful. It can trigger director penalties and invalidate your limited liability protection.

Alternative ways to take income

If you need cash during a loss-making period, consider a director’s loan or temporary salary increase instead. At Zeus, we often use these short-term solutions during a tough quarter to keep clients afloat — while keeping everything fully compliant.

What are the penalties for paying illegal dividends?

It’s not something you want to risk.

How HMRC identifies unlawful dividends

HMRC looks for dividends paid when the company’s accounts show no available profits. They can demand repayment, impose interest, and even reclassify the payments as salary — adding National Insurance on top.

Consequences for directors

If you’re found to have taken unlawful dividends, you may have to repay them personally. In extreme cases, it can even lead to disqualification proceedings under the Companies Act.

Steps to correct an accidental breach

If you’ve already done it accidentally, don’t panic. The fix is usually straightforward — you repay the funds or reclassify them properly. The key is to act fast and seek professional advice before the next filing period.

How are dividends reported on a self-assessment tax return?

You’ll need to include them under the “UK dividends” section of your return.

Where to enter dividend income on your return

Simply list your total gross dividends received from your limited company. Your accountant should provide a figure straight from your year-end accounts.

Documents needed for evidence

Keep your dividend vouchers and minutes — these prove the payments were legitimate. We’ve had clients face HMRC checks years later, and these documents made the process quick and painless.

Common filing mistakes to avoid

Don’t confuse dividends with director’s loan repayments — they’re different. And never report dividends net of tax; they should always be shown gross.

Do I need to run payroll if I only pay myself dividends?

Usually, yes — if you pay yourself any salary.

When payroll registration is optional

If you truly take no salary at all, you don’t need PAYE. But if you take even a small amount (say, £9,100), you must register as an employer.

PAYE compliance for directors

Directors are treated slightly differently under PAYE rules — for example, NI is calculated annually, not monthly. It’s one of those small details that can cause confusion if you’re running payroll manually.

When a minimal salary still requires PAYE setup

We often help new contractors register PAYE through HMRC in under an hour. It’s simple — and it’s essential if you want to stay compliant while maintaining your NI record.

🧾 Practical and Lifestyle Questions

Taxes and compliance aside, paying yourself isn’t just about the numbers — it’s about lifestyle, stability, and peace of mind.

Let’s talk about the real-world side of it.

How much should I leave in my business account after paying myself?

This depends on your overheads, but there’s a rule of thumb we teach every new client.

Setting aside funds for tax and expenses

Always keep at least 25% of your gross income aside for tax (corporation, VAT, and personal). It sounds like a lot — until you see the January tax bill.

Building a working capital buffer

We recommend keeping three months of business expenses in your company account. It gives you breathing space when projects end or invoices are late — which, let’s be honest, happens more than any of us would like.

Avoiding cash flow issues as a contractor

A contractor named Neil once told us, “I felt rich until tax season hit.” He’d drawn too many dividends mid-year without setting money aside. We rebuilt his cash flow plan — and now he sleeps better knowing his tax pot is separate.

Can I pay myself dividends every month like a salary?

Technically, yes — but with caution.

Frequency and timing of dividend payments

There’s no legal restriction on frequency, but dividends should only be declared when profits allow. That’s why quarterly or biannual dividends are safer.

Record-keeping requirements

Even if you pay yourself monthly, every payment needs documentation. We automate this for our clients with accounting software that generates dividend vouchers automatically.

Risks of treating dividends as wages

If HMRC believes your “monthly dividends” are just disguised salary, they could reclassify them and demand NI. So if you do it monthly, make sure your paperwork is airtight.

How do I record dividends in my accounting software?

This part is easy — but often done wrong.

Journals and bookkeeping entries

Record dividends as a transfer from retained earnings to the director’s account. Don’t post them as expenses — they’re not deductible for corporation tax.

Creating dividend vouchers automatically

Most modern software, like Xero or QuickBooks, can generate these in seconds. It’s worth using — it keeps your compliance clean and traceable.

Reconciling dividends in your accounts

At year-end, ensure your dividend total matches the declared amount in your company minutes. It sounds simple, but we’ve had clients whose “accounting shortcuts” cost them hours in HMRC queries.

Can I take dividends instead of a salary when I’m on maternity leave?

You can, but it affects your benefits.

Maternity pay eligibility rules

Statutory Maternity Pay (SMP) is based on salary — not dividends. If your salary is below the lower earnings limit, you won’t qualify for SMP.

How dividends affect maternity benefits

Dividends don’t count as “earnings” for these benefits, so if you rely solely on dividends, you’ll likely receive no SMP.

Tax planning during leave periods

If you’re planning maternity leave, consider increasing your salary temporarily before your qualifying period. We helped a client do exactly this, boosting her SMP entitlement by £151 per week — all within the rules.

Do I need to issue dividend vouchers to myself?

Yes. It’s one of those small but important legal details.

What a dividend voucher must include

Each voucher should show:

• The company name

• Shareholder’s name

• Dividend amount

• Date of payment

When and how to issue them

You can issue them electronically or on paper, but they must exist before or at the time of payment.

Retaining vouchers for HMRC records

Keep them for at least six years. They’re your proof if HMRC ever reviews your company distributions.

How do salary and dividends affect mortgage applications?

This one surprises many contractors.

What lenders look for in contractor income

Lenders often prefer consistent salary income, but many now accept dividends as part of your total earnings — provided your accounts and tax returns are clear.

How to present dividend income as part of earnings

When applying for a mortgage, provide your SA302s and company accounts. We often work directly with contractor-friendly lenders to help clients secure mortgages using their true income picture.

Choosing contractor-friendly lenders

Specialist lenders understand that contractors take low salaries and high dividends. We often refer clients to brokers who handle these cases daily — and the approval rates are much higher.

What happens if I take too much in dividends?

You’ve just created an overdrawn director’s loan account.

Understanding overdrawn director’s loan accounts

This happens when you withdraw more than your company has in post-tax profits.

Repayment obligations and tax charges

If not repaid within nine months of the year-end, your company pays a 32.5% s455 tax charge on the overdrawn balance.

How to correct overpayments

The good news? When you repay the loan, you get the s455 tax back. We helped one client recover nearly £5,000 in overpaid tax after correcting his records.

How do I pay myself if I have multiple directorships?

Coordination is key.

Coordinating income across companies

You need to look at your total income across all directorships when planning dividends. Otherwise, you may accidentally push yourself into a higher tax band.

Managing multiple PAYE records

Each company may need its own PAYE scheme. We help multi-company directors consolidate this into one dashboard for clarity.

Avoiding double taxation issues

Never pay dividends twice on the same profits — this is a common mistake when contractors manage two related companies. A simple consolidation review can prevent that.

Is it better to pay yourself through a management company?

Sometimes — but not always.

When management companies make sense

They can simplify finances if you operate several ventures. One client who ran three small consultancies now pays himself through a single management company for easier admin.

Tax efficiency vs complexity

However, it introduces more admin — intercompany invoicing, VAT, and accounting rules. For most solo contractors, it’s overkill.

Risks of misusing intermediary structures

If set up incorrectly, HMRC may treat the structure as tax avoidance. Always get professional advice before using one.

What’s the impact of the new National Insurance thresholds on my pay strategy?

Summary of 2025 NIC changes

The thresholds have shifted slightly upward, reducing the NI payable on smaller salaries. But for directors, the annual calculation method remains.

Salary optimisation under new thresholds

Most contractors will still target a salary just below the NI threshold to avoid paying NI while retaining state benefits.

Adjusting dividends to balance take-home pay

Since the dividend allowance has shrunk, some contractors are slightly increasing salaries and pension contributions instead — keeping their overall efficiency roughly the same.

🧮 Scenario-Based Questions for Contractors and Small Business Owners

Now let’s bring all this to life with real-world examples.

At Zeus Accountants, we’ve helped hundreds of contractors model these scenarios — and the patterns are consistent.

How much can I pay myself from £50,000 profit tax-efficiently?

Example salary/dividend breakdown

• Salary: £12,570

• Profit after salary: £37,430

• Corporation tax (25%): £9,357

• Available dividends: £28,072

Your take-home after all taxes? Roughly £39,500. That’s nearly £5,000 more than if you’d taken it all as salary.

Total tax comparison

"All salary" - Total Tax ~ £10,500 Take-home Pay ~£39,500

"Salary + Dividends" - Total Tax ~£6,500 Take-home Pay ~£43,500

Optimising for future growth

Leaving a few thousand in the company can help fund expenses or smooth future cash flow. We call it “strategic retention.”

How much should I pay myself if my company makes £100K profit?

Recommended strategy for high-profit contractors

At this level, it’s about staying below the higher-rate threshold where possible and using pensions smartly.

Pension contribution options

For example, you might take:

• Salary: £12,570

• Dividends: £37,700

• Employer pension contribution: £20,000

You’ll stay in the basic rate band, reduce corporation tax, and keep £70,000+ efficiently extracted between income and pension.

Impact of higher-rate thresholds

Every £1 of dividend above the basic rate costs you 33.75p in tax. Smart planning keeps you below that.

How does IR35 status affect how I pay myself?

If you’re inside IR35, you’re essentially treated like an employee.

Income tax treatment under IR35

Your fee payer (usually the client or agency) deducts PAYE tax and NI before payment. That means you can’t take dividends from that income.

Operating outside IR35 and paying dividends

If you’re outside IR35, you have full flexibility. You invoice the client, pay corporation tax, and take dividends — just like a traditional limited company contractor.

Real-world comparison

We’ve seen contractors double their effective take-home pay by moving from inside to outside IR35 (legitimately) through contract restructuring and status reviews.

Should I pay myself a director’s loan instead of dividends?

When loans make sense

If your company is waiting on invoices or has temporary losses, a director’s loan can bridge the gap.

Tax treatment of loans vs dividends

But remember — it’s not income. It must be repaid, and if it isn’t, it can trigger tax charges.

Converting loans to dividends

We often convert loans into dividends at year-end once profits are confirmed — keeping everything compliant and tax-efficient.

How much should I pay myself as a first-year contractor?

Recommended starting structure

• Salary: £9,100 (below NI threshold)

• Dividends: As profits allow

• Keep 25% aside for tax

Avoiding common new-contractor mistakes

Many new contractors pay themselves too early, before earning profits. We help them pace their income — slow and steady always wins.

Balancing personal and business cash flow

Your first year is about stability, not maximising take-home. Once your first accounts are filed, we can fine-tune everything.

⚡ Final Thoughts

Being a contractor gives you incredible control — but only if you understand the system.

At Zeus Accountants, we’re not here just to file your taxes. We’re here to help you build wealth intelligently, stay compliant, and take home more of what you earn — every single year.

If you’d like us to model your exact pay structure — salary, dividends, pension, and tax impact — we’ll do it for free as part of your onboarding.

👉 Book a discovery call today and let’s build your pay plan together.

‍