IR35 Explained for Contractors – 2025 Complete Guide

“The smartest contractors don’t fear IR35 — they understand it and use that knowledge to stay one step ahead.”

IR35 has been around for more than two decades, yet it still trips up thousands of UK contractors every year. Whether you’re new to contracting or a seasoned professional, understanding IR35 is essential if you want to protect your income, stay compliant, and keep your business running smoothly.

If you’ve ever sat at your desk, calculator in hand, trying to figure out whether IR35 applies to your contract, you’re not alone. IR35 remains one of the most confusing, frustrating, and frankly misunderstood parts of the UK tax system — especially for contractors.

As accountants, we’ve seen contractors lose thousands through poor advice, while others have confidently navigated IR35 and thrived. The truth? Once you understand what IR35 really means, it becomes far less intimidating — and far more manageable.

At Zeus Accountants, we specialise in helping UK contractors navigate IR35 with clarity and confidence. In this complete guide, we’ll explain exactly what IR35 is, who it affects, how it changes your take-home pay, and how to stay on the right side of the rules — without losing the freedom and flexibility that make contracting so rewarding.

Let’s start with the basics.

General IR35 Understanding

What does IR35 actually mean for contractors?

IR35 is essentially a set of tax rules designed to identify people who work like employees but bill their clients through limited companies — often called Personal Service Companies (PSCs) — to pay less tax.

If HMRC decides you’re effectively an employee, your contract is said to be “inside IR35.”

That means you’ll pay tax and National Insurance much like a full-time worker, but without employee benefits such as holiday pay or pension contributions.

The goal of IR35 is simple: to prevent “disguised employment.” The challenge for contractors is proving that you’re genuinely in business on your own account.

In simple terms:

If you look, act, and work like an employee, HMRC might decide you are one for tax purposes. And that’s when you’re said to be “inside IR35.”

How IR35 defines employment status

HMRC uses three key tests:

1. Control – Does the client tell you how, when, and where to work?

2. Substitution – Can you send someone else to do the job instead of you?

3. Mutuality of obligation – Is there an expectation that you’ll keep working and they’ll keep paying you, like a regular job?

Fail these tests, and you’re likely inside IR35.

Key tests used to assess IR35 status

HMRC doesn’t just look at your contract; it examines how you actually work.

For example, if your client provides all your tools, dictates your hours, and invites you to the staff Christmas party — that’s a red flag.

But if you set your own hours, provide your own equipment, and have multiple clients — you’re behaving more like a business.

When did IR35 rules start in the UK?

IR35 was first introduced in April 2000. Since then, it’s been reformed several times — most notably in 2017 for public sector contractors and 2021 for private sector ones.

Under the current system, if you work for a medium or large client, that client decides whether your contract is inside or outside IR35.

It was designed to stop “disguised employment,” where individuals acted as limited companies purely to reduce tax.

Timeline of IR35 introduction and reforms

• 2000: Original IR35 legislation launched.

• 2017: Public sector reform – the responsibility for determining IR35 status moved from the contractor to the public sector client.

• 2021: Private sector reform – large and medium companies took on that same responsibility.

• 2025: Ongoing reviews, but the fundamentals remain the same.

Key legislative milestones since 2000

The 2021 reform was the real game-changer.

Before then, contractors assessed themselves. Now, the end client (unless they’re a small company) decides whether you’re inside or outside IR35 — and they bear the tax risk.

Why was IR35 introduced?

Tackling disguised employment

HMRC noticed a growing number of people doing full-time work under limited company contracts to avoid PAYE and National Insurance.

IR35 was designed to make sure these individuals paid roughly the same tax as regular employees.

Ensuring fair tax treatment

The goal wasn’t to punish contractors. It was to ensure a level playing field — where genuine businesses weren’t undercut by disguised employees benefiting from tax advantages without the employment risks. However, the line between genuine self-employment and disguised employment is rarely clear-cut, which is where professional IR35 reviews come in.

How does IR35 affect take-home pay?

The financial impact is significant, as the most noticeable impact is on your net income.

Differences in net income inside vs outside IR35

If you’re outside IR35, you can take advantage of tax-efficient structures like a small salary and dividends and pay yourself in the most tax-efficient way for limited company directors.

If you’re inside IR35, your income is treated as employment income, where you will pay Income Tax and National Insurance Contributions (NICs) at source via PAYE.

Example of typical tax impact

Let’s say you earn £500 per day:

• Outside IR35: You might take home around £390 per day after tax.

• Inside IR35: Expect closer to £320 per day, depending on your rate and expenses.

That’s roughly a 20–25% reduction in take-home pay. It stings — but with smart planning, it’s manageable.

Is IR35 the same as self-employment tax rules?

How IR35 differs from normal self-employment

No. Self-employed individuals are taxed on business profits, not PAYE income.

IR35 applies to limited company contractors, not sole traders.

When IR35 overrides self-employed status

Even if you think you’re self-employed, if you work through a limited company and your client treats you like an employee, IR35 can still apply.

What’s the difference between IR35 and PAYE?

PAYE vs deemed employment

PAYE (Pay As You Earn) is the standard employee tax system. IR35 introduces “deemed employment” — where you’re taxed like an employee, but without employment rights like holiday pay or sick leave.

Who deducts tax and National Insurance

If you’re inside IR35, the fee payer (often your agency or client) deducts tax and NIC before paying you.

Can IR35 apply to part-time contracts?

IR35 tests for part-time or flexible arrangements

Yes. IR35 doesn’t care about hours or days worked — only working practices. Even if you work part-time, if your working practices mirror employment — regular hours, client control, and no substitution — you can still be inside IR35. Even a one-day-a-week contract can fall inside IR35 if the client controls your work or you’re treated like part of their team.

Common misconceptions

Some contractors think working fewer hours keeps them safe. Unfortunately, it’s not about hours — it’s about control and independence.

🧑‍💼 Who IR35 Applies To

Does IR35 apply to freelancers as well as contractors?

IR35 relevance to different working arrangements

It depends on how you’re structured. Freelancers operating as sole traders aren’t affected.

Those working through limited companies might be.

Freelancers vs limited company contractors

If you invoice through your company and work for one main client, IR35 could easily apply.

Does IR35 apply to sole traders?

Why sole traders are outside IR35 scope

No. IR35 only applies when there’s an intermediary — usually your limited company. Sole traders are taxed directly — there’s no “intermediary” company between them and the client. So IR35 doesn’t apply, but HMRC can still challenge your employment status under different rules.

Alternative tax rules affecting sole traders

However, you’re still subject to employment status tests for tax and employment law purposes — so “disguised employment” can still be challenged under different rules.

Can I work through an umbrella company to avoid IR35?

How umbrella companies handle PAYE compliance

Yes — and many contractors do. When you join an umbrella company, you become their employee. The umbrella handles PAYE, tax, NICs, and holiday pay. You’ll take home less, but it simplifies compliance and removes risk.

Pros and cons

You gain simplicity and employment benefits (like holiday pay), but lose some tax efficiency and flexibility. Still, it’s a clean solution if most of your contracts are inside IR35.

Who determines if I fall inside or outside IR35?

Client responsibility vs contractor responsibility

Since 2021, medium and large private companies and public sector clients decide your status.

If your client is a small company, the responsibility stays with you.

How Status Determination Statements (SDS) work

Clients must issue a Status Determination Statement explaining their IR35 decision — and their reasoning. If you disagree, you can challenge it. At Zeus Accountants, we always review SDS documents to make sure they’re fair and accurate.

Can a client make me inside IR35?

The client’s assessment process

Yes, but they must take “reasonable care” in making that decision. If they don’t, you have grounds to appeal through the client’s disagreement process — and you should.

How to challenge an inside IR35 decision

Write to your client within 45 days, explaining why you disagree. Provide evidence like contracts, substitution clauses, and actual working practices.

Does IR35 apply to overseas contractors working for UK companies?

UK tax residency and IR35 scope

If you’re UK tax resident, IR35 applies to your UK contracts.

When overseas engagements fall outside IR35

If the client has no UK presence and you’re working overseas, IR35 usually doesn’t apply — though local tax laws might.

Does IR35 affect public and private sector contractors differently?

The rules are largely the same now. The main difference is who decides your status and who bears the risk — the client in most cases, except when they qualify as a small business.

Public sector IR35 reforms (2017)

Since 2017, public sector bodies (like the NHS or local councils) determine your IR35 status.

Private sector IR35 changes (2021)

The same rule now applies in the private sector — except when the client is “small.” That’s defined by the Companies Act (two of the following: turnover under £10.2m, balance sheet under £5.1m, fewer than 50 employees).

📜 Inside vs Outside IR35

What are the benefits of being outside IR35?

Tax efficiency and flexibility

You can take dividends, plan your income, and deduct legitimate business expenses.

It’s the most financially rewarding way to work — if your setup is compliant.

Greater control

You call the shots. You choose clients, working hours, and methods — the hallmarks of a genuine business.

What are the downsides of being inside IR35?

Reduced take-home pay

You’ll likely lose 20–25% of your income to PAYE deductions.

Limited expenses and no employment rights

You’re taxed like an employee but get none of the benefits. No sick pay, no pension match — just higher tax.

Can a contract change from outside to inside IR35?

Triggers for change

Yes — if your working practices evolve. If your client, for example asks for fixed hours or closer supervision, or removes your substitution rights, your IR35 position may shift.

How to manage it

Review contracts regularly. Document changes. Transparency protects you.

Can I negotiate my way out of IR35?

Rewriting contracts for compliance

Absolutely. Contracts matter. By rewriting the contract to reflect genuine business independence — and aligning it with your real working practices — you can strengthen your position.

Independent reviews

Zeus Accountants regularly reviews contracts and provides written IR35 compliance letters to support clients in negotiations.

Is it illegal to work outside IR35?

Not at all — as long as you’re genuinely self-employed. It’s only an issue if your contract says you’re outside IR35 but you actually work like an employee

Misclassification vs legitimacy

Trouble only arises if you pretend to be outside IR35 when you’re not.

How can I structure my contract to stay outside IR35?

Key clauses

Include substitution rights, control over working hours, and clear deliverables.

Aligning reality

Make sure your actual day-to-day work matches your contract. HMRC looks at what happens in practice.

Are fixed-term contracts usually inside IR35?

Often, yes — but not always.

Proving independence

If you work autonomously, use your own tools, and take business risks, you can still be outside IR35 even on a fixed term.

🧮 Taxes & Payments

How is tax calculated if I’m inside IR35?

Deemed payment calculation

Your income is treated like salary. PAYE and NICs are deducted before you receive payment.

Employer’s NIC

The fee payer covers employer NIC — not you directly, but it reduces the rate they’re willing to pay.

Can I still claim expenses if I’m inside IR35?

5% allowance rules

If you’re working for a small client and still determining your own status, you can claim a flat 5% allowance for admin costs.

But for most contractors post-2021, that allowance no longer applies.

What expenses remain

You can still claim business insurance, professional subscriptions, and pension contributions.

How much more tax will I pay inside IR35?

Example comparison

A contractor earning £100,000 outside IR35 might pay around £20,000 less tax than one inside.

Planning tip

Consider adjusting your day rate if you’re inside IR35 to account for the difference.

What happens to my dividends if I’m inside IR35?

They don’t apply for inside IR35 income — since you’re paid under PAYE.

You can still take dividends from retained profits earned from previous outside IR35 work.

Do I still need to file a company tax return?

Yes. Even inside IR35, your limited company still exists.

Your accountant will include both IR35 income and company expenses in your accounts.

Does IR35 affect VAT registration?

No — you can remain VAT registered.

Just remember: VAT still applies to your invoices, even if the payment is processed through PAYE.

How can I reduce my tax bill if I’m caught by IR35?

Smart strategies

• Contribute to a pension.

• Claim allowable business expenses.

• Use professional advice to structure payments efficiently.

Good planning can soften the blow significantly.

🕵️ HMRC Investigations & Compliance

How does HMRC check IR35 status?

They use data from RTI submissions, client records, and sometimes whistleblowers.

Record keeping matters

Keep contracts, emails, invoices, and evidence of substitution or multiple clients.

What triggers an investigation?

Red flags

Working long-term for a single client, using client equipment, or appearing on staff lists.

Prevention

Annual IR35 reviews keep you safe.

What happens during an enquiry?

HMRC sends a letter asking questions about your contracts and working practices.

How to respond

Never ignore it. Engage an accountant or IR35 specialist immediately.

What evidence does HMRC look for?

Emails showing control, exclusivity, or fixed hours can hurt your case.

Proof of independence — like multiple clients or your own insurance — helps defend it.

How long does an IR35 investigation take?

Anywhere from six months to two years, depending on complexity.

The more organised your documentation, the faster it resolves.

How can I protect myself from IR35 risk?

Regular contract reviews, written agreements reflecting real working practices, and professional indemnity insurance all help.

What are the penalties for getting IR35 wrong?

Backdated tax, interest, and sometimes penalties of up to 30% — or more if HMRC believes you acted “carelessly.”

But reasonable care (e.g., independent advice) can protect you.

📅 Rules & Exemptions

Who qualifies for small business exemption?

A company is “small” if it meets two of these:

• Turnover under £10.2m

• Balance sheet under £5.1m

• Fewer than 50 staff

Small clients mean you, the contractor, determine IR35 status — not them.

Does IR35 apply if I work for multiple clients?

Usually not — multiple concurrent clients show you’re in business on your own account.

Still, each contract must be assessed separately.

Does IR35 apply to short-term contracts?

Yes — even short projects can fall inside IR35 if working practices resemble employment.

Are charities exempt?

No — unless they qualify as “small.”

Charities often assume exemption, but that’s a mistake.

Is there a minimum income threshold?

No — IR35 can apply at any income level.

Are directors affected?

Yes. If you’re a director providing services through your own company, IR35 can still apply.

How often should I review my IR35 status?

At least once a year, or whenever your contract changes.

An annual IR35 review is good business hygiene — like an MOT for your tax status.

🧠 Practical Scenarios & Planning

Can I switch from a permanent job to contracting outside IR35?

Yes — but plan it properly.

Set up your limited company, get professional advice, and ensure your first contract reflects genuine independence.

Can I work both inside and outside IR35?

Absolutely.

Many contractors juggle inside and outside contracts.

Just keep your accounts crystal clear — separate invoices, records, and payslips.

How does IR35 affect my pension?

Inside IR35, you can still make pension contributions via your company and claim tax relief. It’s one of the smartest ways to offset higher tax.

How do umbrella companies help?

They take away admin. You become their employee, and they handle PAYE, insurance, and compliance.

For some, the peace of mind is worth the cost.

Should I close my limited company if I’m caught by IR35?

Not necessarily.

Many contractors keep their company dormant between contracts or use it for outside IR35 work.

Can IR35 affect mortgage applications?

Yes — lenders view inside IR35 income as less predictable.

Provide consistent payslips and accountant references to strengthen your application.

How do I appeal an IR35 decision?

Use the client-led disagreement process.

If that fails, seek professional review — or escalate to HMRC if necessary.

🔮 Future of IR35

Will IR35 rules change again?

Almost certainly — it’s a political hot potato.

The government periodically reviews it, and contractors continue to push for reform.

Are there plans to simplify IR35?

Yes — industry bodies are lobbying for clearer, fairer rules.

Even HMRC admits it’s complex.

How will a repeal affect contractors?

If IR35 were scrapped, we’d likely see a resurgence of limited company contracting.

But until then, it’s best to plan under the current law.

What happens to contracts if IR35 is scrapped?

They’ll simply revert to standard business-to-business agreements.

Flexibility would return — but so would responsibility.

Should I plan around possible IR35 changes?

Absolutely.

Stay agile. Keep your contracts flexible, your company active, and your accountant close.

IR35 may evolve, but smart contractors will always adapt.

Final Thoughts

At Zeus Accountants, we’ve seen how the right IR35 strategy can transform a contractor’s confidence — and their bottom line.

IR35 isn’t just about tax; it’s about control, clarity, and confidence in your working future.

If you’re unsure about your current contract or want a professional IR35 review, speak to us today — we’ll help you stay compliant and keep more of what you earn.

‍